You are watching: Si and am lady and the tramp
Disney+ is filled v over 600 titles pulled from eight decades of entertainment starting with 1937’s Snow White and the seven Dwarfs (the first-ever feature-length animated film) every the way to 2019’s Avengers: Endgame (the greatest movie ever). That’s left Disney with a dilemma: just how do lock handle facets of their library the were absolutely misguided yet maybe no controversial 50 years ago? and also what perform they do if among their new offerings is a remake that includes one of those yikes-inducing moments?
That’s specifically the conundrum Disney faced with your live-action remake of the 1955 animated classic Lady and the Tramp. The film has actually been a major part of the Disney canon because that 60 years, for this reason it was bound to obtain the live-action treatment eventually. There’s only one catch: “The Siamese Cat Song.”
The tune was co-written and also performed through Norma Deloris Egstrom, known professionally by her stage name Peggy Lee. She to be a major singing star of the era, and getting Peggy Lee in a Disney movie was a big deal. The problem? The “Siamese Cat Song” is a racialism caricature the what white civilization thought of asian people at the time. Their names are racist (“Si” and also “Am”), their design is racist (those teeth), your voices room racist (that broken English and accent), and also the music is racialism (that gong). Their duty in the plot is likewise racist: these eastern absolutely rubbish Lady’s home, and frame her for the whole thing. They’re fully villains.
The cat were additionally not part of the source material, back the funny thing about Lady and the Tramp is that the story actually precedes the credited source material. The film at first started in 1937, approximately the time Snow White to be released, when Disney artist Joe approve came up with a story about his English Springer Spaniel, called Lady, being jealous of his brand-new baby. Walt Disney love the idea and also the film was put into production, which kind of eschewed the frequently accepted Disney methodology the adapting fairy tales and classic literature. This would’ve probably been Disney’s very first original feature film, until Disney check out a story created by Ward Greene released in Cosmopolitan.
Published in 1945, Happy Dan, The downhearted Dogadded the Tramp component of the Lady and the Tramp equation. The story was about a con artist dog that tricked civilization out of your food (as Tramp go in the film). Disney purchase the rights to the story and thus Lady became Lady and also the Tramp. It to be also, apparently, Disney’s idea to include a pair of mischievous Siamese cat to the tale.
In 2019, though, we understand that this depiction of Si and Am is reductive of eastern culture, and also Disney has actually updated it because that the remake. Rather of “The Siamese Cat Song,” the two intruders sing a number referred to as “What a Shame.” instead of gift Siamese cats, the pair room thin gray cats through dark stripes. Instead of having a gong-filled, vaguely eastern sound, “What a Shame” is an upbeat, ragtime-influenced blues number similar to what was renowned with audience in the early 1900s, once the movie is set. Rather of this ragtime song, a genre v roots in turn-of-the-century African-American communities, being sung by a white show (like Peggy Lee singing a vaguely eastern song in the ’50s), “What a Shame” is written and also performed by black artists, brothers and frequent Janelle Monae collaborators Nate “Rocket” Wonder and also Roman GianArthur. And also instead of the cats being the only personalities in the movie coded together “other,” the new Lady and also the Tramp features a live-action and voice actors filled with performers the color.
This isn’t the only number native Wonder and GianArthur in the film, either. They also produced Monae’s version of “He’s a Tramp” and also the initial song “That’s Enough.” You deserve to hear much more of Wonder’s work-related with his funk duo Deep Cotton, and GianArthur has collaborated v Monae on she albums The ArchAndroid and The electric Lady.
See more: What Feature Is Found In All Mollusks? ? Reading: Mollusks
That’s just how Disney course-corrected because that the remake, by changing up an facet of the story the wasn’t a part of the original animator’s pitch and also wasn’t part of the credited source material. And also that food correction offered the Disney canon a new musical number that’s one homage to the moment period. However fans of culturally appropriative, inaccurate, and also insensitive musical numbers native 60 years back needn’t worry: the tune is still consisted of in the original animated film.