Explain the concept of labor unions, including membership levels and also wagesEvaluate disagreements for and against labor unionsAnalyze factors for the decrease in U.S. Union membership

A labor union is an company of employees that negotiates with employers end wages and working conditions. A job union looks for to change the balance that power between employers and workers by requiring job to attend to workers collectively, rather than as individuals. Thus, negotiations between unions and also firms room sometimes dubbed collective bargaining.

You are watching: How do unions affect the natural rate of unemployment

The subject of job unions deserve to be controversial. Supporters of labor unions watch them together the workers’ major line the defense versus efforts through profit-seeking this firm to hold down wages and benefits. Doubters of job unions see them as having a tendency to seize as much as they have the right to in the quick term, also if it means injuring employees in the long run by control firms into bankruptcy or by impede the new technologies and production approaches that lead to economic growth. We will begin with some facts about union membership in the joined States.

Facts about Union Membership and Pay

According come the U.S. Bureau of Labor and also Statistics, about 11.1% of every U.S. Workers belong to unions. Complying with are some of the facts provided by the bureau for 2014:

12.0% the U.S. Male employees belong to unions; 10.5% that female workers do11.1% of white workers, 13.4 % of black workers, and 9.8 % that Hispanic workers belong come unions12.5% of full-time workers and 6.0% that part-time workers room union members4.2% of workers eras 16–24 belong come unions, as do 14% the workers ages 45-54Occupations in which fairly high percentages of workers belong to unions are the federal government (26.9% belong come a union), state federal government (31.3%), local federal government (41.7%); transportation and also utilities (20.6%); herbal resources, construction, and also maintenance (16.3%); and production, transportation, and also material moving (14.7%)Occupations the have reasonably low percentages the unionized workers are farming workers (1.4%), financial services (1.1%), professional and business services (2.4%), recreation and hospitality (2.7%), and also wholesale and retail profession (4.7%)

In summary, the percent of employees belonging come a union is higher for men than women; greater for blacks than for whites or Hispanics; greater for the 45–64 period range; and higher among workers in government and also manufacturing than workers in farming or service-oriented jobs. Table 2 list the largest U.S. Job unions and also their membership.

National education Association (NEA)3.2 million
Service Employees global Union (SEIU)2.1 million
American Federation of teacher (AFT)1.5 million
International Brotherhood of Teamsters (IBT)1.4 million
The American Federation the State, County, and Municipal employees (AFSCME)1.3 million
United Food and Commercial Workers global Union1.3 million
United Steelworkers1.2 million
International Union, joined Automobile, Aerospace and farming Implement employees of America (UAW)990,000
International association of Machinists and Aerospace Workers720,000
International Brotherhood of electric Workers (IBEW)675,000
Table 2. The biggest American unions in 2013. (Source: U.S. Room of Labor, bureau of job Statistics)

In regards to pay, benefits, and hiring, U.S. Unions sell a an excellent news/bad news story. The good news because that unions and also their members is that their members earn about 20% much more than nonunion workers, even after adjusting for components such together years of work experience and also education level. The poor news because that unions is the the share of U.S. Workers that belong to a job union has actually been steadily declining for 50 years, as shown in number 1. Around one-quarter of all U.S. Employees belonged to a union in the mid-1950s, yet only 11.1% the U.S. Workers are union members today. If you leave out employees employed through the federal government (which contains teachers in publicly schools), only 6.6% of the employees employed by private firms now work for a union.

Figure 1. percent of Wage and also Salary workers Who space Union Members. The share of wage and salary workers that belong come unions rose sharply in the 1930s and 1940s, yet has tailed off since then to 11.1% of all employees in 2014.

The adhering to section analyzes the higher pay union workers receive compared the pay rates for nonunion workers. The adhering to section analyzes decreasing union member levels. An overview of this two issues will enable us to comment on many elements of exactly how unions work.

Higher salaries for Union Workers

Why could union employees receive higher pay? What space the borders on exactly how much higher pay they have the right to receive? To analyze these questions, let’s take into consideration a situation where all firms in an industry must negotiate through a single union, and no firm is permitted to hire nonunion labor. If no job union existed in this market, climate equilibrium (E) in the labor sector would occur at the intersection the the need for labor (D) and the supply of labor (S) in number 2. The union can, however, threaten that, unless firms agree come the incomes they demand, the workers will certainly strike. Together a result, the labor union manages to achieve, with negotiations with the firms, a union fairy of Wu because that its members, over what the equilibrium wage would certainly otherwise have actually been.

Figure 2. Union wage Negotiations. Without a union, the equilibrium at E would have involved the wage We and also the amount of job Qe. However, the union is may be to usage its bargaining strength to advanced the wage to Wu. The result is one excess it is provided of labor for union jobs. That is, a amount of labor supplied, Qs is greater than firms’ quantity demanded for labor, Qd.

This labor market case resembles what a monopoly firm does in marketing a product, however in this situation a union is a syndicate selling labor to firms. At the greater union wage Wu, the this firm in this sector will hire much less labor 보다 they would have hired in equilibrium. Moreover, an excess it is provided of workers desire union jobs, but firms will certainly not be hiring for such jobs.

From the union suggest of view, workers who receive higher wages are better off. However, an alert that the amount of employees (Qd) rental at the union fairy Wu is smaller sized than the quantity Qe that would have actually been hired at the initial equilibrium wage. A judicious union must recognize that once it pushes up the wage, it likewise reduces the inspiration of firms to hire. This case does not necessarily median that union workers room fired. Instead, it may be that once union workers move on come other work or retire, they are not constantly replaced. Or perhaps when a firm increases production, it increases employment somewhat less with a greater union wage than it would have actually done through the reduced equilibrium wage. Or perhaps a for sure decides to acquisition inputs from nonunion producers, rather than creating them with its own highly paid unionized workers. Or possibly the firm move or opens a brand-new facility in a state or nation where unions are less powerful.

From the firm’s point of view, the key question is whether the greater wage that union employees is matched by higher productivity. If so, climate the firm deserve to afford to pay the greater union earnings and, indeed, the need curve for “unionized” labor could actually transition to the right. This can reduce the job losses together the equilibrium employed staff level shifts to the right and the difference in between the equilibrium and the union salaries will have actually been reduced. If worker unionization go not rise productivity, then the higher union fairy will cause lower profits or losses because that the firm.

Union workers can have higher productivity than nonunion workers for a number of reasons. First, higher wages might elicit higher productivity. Second, union workers often tend to stay much longer at a given job, a tendency that reduce the employer’s prices for training and also hiring and results in employees with much more years the experience. Countless unions also offer project training and apprenticeship programs.

In addition, firms the are faced with union demands for greater wages may pick production techniques that involve much more physical capital and also less labor, resulting in raised labor productivity. Table 3 offers an example. Assume that a certain can develop a house exercise cycle with three various combinations of labor and also manufacturing equipment. Say that labor is payment $16 an hour (including benefits) and also the equipments for manufacturing expense $200 each. Under this circumstances, the total cost of producing a home exercise cycle will certainly be lowest if the firm adopts the setup of 50 hours of labor and one machine, as the table shows. Now, intend that a union negotiates a wage of $20 one hour consisting of benefits. In this case, it provides no distinction to the firm whether it uses much more hours the labor and also fewer makers or less labor and much more machines, despite it could prefer to use much more machines and to rental fewer union workers. (After all, machines never threaten to strike—but they perform not buy the final product or company either.) In the last column of the table, the wage has risen come $24 one hour. In this case, the firm plainly has an motivation for utilizing the arrangement that involves paying for fewer hours of labor and also using three machines. If management responds come union needs for greater wages through investing more in machinery, climate union workers can be an ext productive because they are working with an ext or far better physical funding equipment 보다 the usual nonunion worker. However, the firm will must hire fewer workers.

Hours of LaborNumber of MachinesCost of job + price of an equipment $16/hourCost of job + expense of machine $20/hourCost of job + price of machine $24/hr
303$480 + $600 = $1,080$600 + $600 = $1,200$720 + $600 = $1,320
402$640 + $400 = $1,040$800 + $400 = $1,200$960 + $400 = $1,360
501$800 + $200 = $1,000$1,000 + $200 = $1,200$1,200 + $200 = $1,400
Table 3. three Production choices to manufacture a residence Exercise Cycle

In some cases, unions have actually discouraged the use of labor-saving physical funding equipment—out of the reasonable are afraid that brand-new machinery will minimize the variety of union jobs. Because that example, in 2002, the union representing longshoremen that unload ships and also the firms that run shipping companies and port infrastructure staged a occupational stoppage the shut down the harbor on the western shore of the united States. Two key issues in the problem were the desire the the shipping companies and also port operators to use handheld scanners because that record-keeping and also computer-operated cabs for loading and also unloading ships—changes i beg your pardon the union opposed, along with overtime pay. Chairman Obama intimidated to use the Labor monitoring Relations action of 1947—commonly well-known as the Taft-Hartley Act—where a court have the right to impose an 80-day “cooling-off period” in stimulate to permit time for negotiations to continue without the threat of a work-related stoppage. Federal mediators were referred to as in, and also the two sides agreed to a transaction in February 2015. The ultimate agreement enabled the brand-new technologies, but also kept wages, health, and also pension benefits high for workers. In the past, presidential usage of the Taft-Hartley act sometimes has made labor negotiations more bitter and argumentative but, in this case, it seems to have actually smoothed the road to an agreement.

In other instances, unions have actually proved fairly willing to adopt new technologies. In one significant example, during the 1950s and 1960s, the United Mineworkers union demanded the mining providers install labor-saving machine in the mines. The mineworkers’ union realized that over time, the new machines would alleviate the number of jobs in the mines, however the union leaders likewise knew the the mine owner would have to pay greater wages if the employees became more productive, and also mechanization was a necessary step toward higher productivity.

In fact, in some situations union workers may be more willing to accept brand-new technology 보다 nonunion workers, since the union workers think that the union will certainly negotiate to safeguard their jobs and also wages, vice versa, nonunion workers might be more concerned the the new technology will change their jobs. In addition, union workers, who commonly have greater job market experience and also training, are most likely to experience less and also benefit much more than non-union workers from the arrival of new technology. Overall, that is difficult to make a definitive instance that union workers as a group are always either much more or less welcoming to brand-new technology than room nonunion workers.

The decline in U.S. Union Membership

The relationship of U.S. Employees belonging to union has declined dramatically since the early on 1950s. Economists have available a variety of possible explanations:

The shift from manufacturing to service industriesThe pressure of globalization and increased vain from foreign producersA reduced desire because that unions since of the workplace protection laws now in placeU.S. Legal setting that makes it fairly more complicated for unions to organize workers and also expand your membership

Let’s comment on each that these 4 explanations in more detail.

A an initial possible explanation for the decline in the re-publishing of U.S. Employees belonging to unions requires the patterns of job development in the manufacturing and service sectors that the economy presented in number 3. The U.S. Economy had around 15 million manufacturing work in 1960. This full rose to 19 million by the late 1970s and also then declined to 17 million in 2013. Meanwhile, the number of jobs in service industries and also in government linked rose native 35 million in 1960 to end 118 million by 2013, follow to the office of job Statistics. Because over time union were stronger in manufacturing than in business industries, the growth in jobs was no happening wherein the unions were. That is interesting to keep in mind that several of the best unions in the country are comprised of federal government workers, including the American Federation the State, County and also Municipal employee (AFSCME); the Service Employees worldwide Union; and the National education and learning Association. The membership of every of these unions is detailed in Table 2. Exterior of government employees, however, unions have actually not had an excellent success in arranging the organization sector.

Figure 3. The expansion of business Jobs. Tasks in services have increased significantly in the last few decades. Jobs in government have boosted modestly. Jobs in manufacturing have not adjusted much, return they have actually trended down in current years. Source: U.S. Department of Labor, office of job Statistics.

A second explanation because that the decline in the re-publishing of unionized employees looks at import competition. Beginning in the 1960s, U.S. Carmakers and also steelmakers faced increasing competition from Japanese and also European manufacturers. As sales of imported cars and steel rose, the number of jobs in U.S. Auto production fell. This market is heavily unionized. No surprisingly, member in the united Auto Workers, which was 975,000 in 1985, had actually fallen to roughly 390,000 by 2015. Import competition not just decreases the employment in sectors where unions were once strong, but likewise decreases the bargaining power of union in those sectors. However, together we have actually seen, unions that organize public-sector workers, who space not threatened by import competition, have continued to view growth.

A third feasible reason because that the decrease in the variety of union workers is that citizens often call on their chosen representatives to pass laws worrying work conditions, overtime, parental leave, regulation the pensions, and also other issues. Unions offered strong political support for these regulations aimed in ~ protecting employees but, in one ironic twist, the passage of those laws then made many workers feel much less need for unions.

These first three feasible reasons because that the decline of unions space all somewhat plausible, however they have a typical problem. Most other arisen economies have experienced similar economic and also political trends, such as the change from manufacturing to services, globalization, and also increasing government social benefits and also regulation that the workplace. Plainly there are social differences in between countries as to their acceptance of unions in the workplace. The share of the population belonging to union in other nations is an extremely high contrasted with the re-superstructure in the joined States. Table 4 shows the proportion of employees in a variety of the world’s high-income economic climates who belong to unions. The United states is close to the bottom, in addition to France and Spain. The last pillar shows union coverage, identified as including those employees whose wages are established by a union negotiation even if the workers execute not officially belong to the union. In the unified States, union member is almost identical come union coverage. However, in countless countries, the wages of plenty of workers who carry out not official belong to a union are still determined by cumulative bargaining between unions and firms.

CountryUnion Density: percent of workers Belonging to a UnionUnion Coverage: percentage of workers Whose incomes Are figured out by Union Bargaining
United Kingdom29%35%
United States11.1%12.5%
Table 4. global Comparisons of Union Membership and Coverage in 2012. (Source, CIA civilization Factbook, retrieved indigenous www.cia.gov)

These international differences in union membership imply a 4th reason for the decline of union membership in the unified States: possibly U.S. Legislations are much less friendly to the formation of unions 보다 such laws in other countries. The close connection in between union membership and also a friendly legal atmosphere is evident in the history of U.S. Unions. The an excellent rise in union membership in the 1930s followed the i of the National Labor-Management connections Act of 1935, which mentioned that workers had a appropriate to organize unions and also that management had to offer them a fair possibility to execute so. The U.S. Government strongly urged the development of unions during the at an early stage 1940s in the belief that union would help to coordinate the all-out production initiatives needed during people War II. However, after world War II came the passage of the Taft-Hartley action of 1947, which gave states the power to allow workers to opt the end of the union in their workplace if they for this reason desired. This regulation made the legal climate less encouraging come those seeking to kind unions, and also union member levels shortly started declining.

The procedures for forming a union differ significantly from nation to country. For example, the procedures in the united States and also those in Canada space strikingly different. Once a team of employees wish to form a union in the joined States, lock announce this fact and also an election day is set when the employee at a firm will vote in a an enig ballot on even if it is to type a union. Pendant of the union lobby for a “yes” vote, and the management of the certain lobbies because that a “no” vote—often even hiring outside consultants for help in swaying employees to poll “no.” In Canada, by contrast, a union is created when a adequate proportion of employees (usually around 60%) authorize an official card saying the they want a union. Over there is no different “election date.” The administration of Canadian this firm is minimal by regulation in its capacity to lobby against the union. In addition, though it is illegal come discriminate and fire workers based upon their union task in the unified States, the penalties room slight, making this a no so costly way of deterring union activity. In short, creating unions is much easier in Canada—and in numerous other countries—than in the unified States.

See more: Why Did The Professional Dog Walker Do? The Top 5 Reasons You Should Hire A Dog Walker

In summary, union membership in the United says is reduced than in countless other high-income countries, a distinction that might be due to different legal environments and social attitudes towards unions.